Should they be treated like adults? Kids can and in fact do grow up; and as they develop, they change. Humes illustrated examples in paragraphs 4, 5, 6, and 7 by discussing two youth offenders and the punishment that they where sentenced to after being processed through the current laws used by the Juvenile Court System.
From personal experience dealing with a stepsister that has been in and out of the Juvenile Courts since the age of 12, I have found Humes views to be correct. I can see how this is important due to a growing number of murders committed by juveniles but this law doesnt protect juveniles that commit petty crimes such as theft and burglary.
In Massachusetts, any child age 14 or older who is charged with murder is automatically tried as an adult. However, I disagreed with the way she was sentenced because of her age and the crimes she was convicted for.
Jean Trounstine, one of the co-authors of this article, met Karter Reed when he was 32, on a trip with her students to the prison in Shirley, Massachusetts, where he was then housed, to hear him and others convicted of murder speak about their crimes and growing transformation.
He had stabbed a boy in a school, an inviolate space, something we now know too much of; and he was a poor kid committing a brutal crime in a relatively well-to-do neighborhood. In this article, the authors appeal to emotion is that of concern and sadness for the juveniles that are processed through the court system without a second thought as to what will become of these young offenders.
Is the Media to Blame? Page 1 of 2. At the heart of the groundbreaking case, Miller v. I believe that Humes is trying to express a concern that most people have surrounding youth crime which is the fact that we dont want to send children to adult jail so that they can learn to become better criminals.
He might have received therapy and more education, and while Reed did not fear rape or being pummeled by older prisoners, many young people sent to adult prisons and jails do. How do we save first-time offenders from lives of crime How do we turn the best of our legal profession toward saving children From those questions Humes states: That means, the Supreme Court took Miller one step further.
I believe that with help she could have bettered her self and finished school. Dilulio, and John P. They get GEDs, create better family relationships, and if they are given the opportunity, choose to do programs that benefit their development.
Citizens commit scary crimes for different motives. The age that a teenager can be tried, as an adult in most states is 16 in some states they are trying to lower the age to Walters incorrectly warned at this time that teen-age boys would be flooding our streets--joining gangs, dealing drugs, assaulting, raping and murdering--as if there was no end to their viciousness.jail, and one in five of these youth will have spent over six months in an adult jail Adult Prisons: On any given day, approximately young people are locked up in adult prisons.
15 The majority of youth held in adult prisons are not the most serious offenders and are. Juveniles constitute 1, of the million people housed in federal and state prisons in this country, and nearlyyouth enter the adult criminal-justice system each year, most for non-violent crimes.
On any given day, 10, juveniles are housed in adult prisons and jails. These children lose more than their freedom when they enter adult. Feb 09, · Children as young as 8, 10, 12, or 13 have been tried as adults, and 14 states have no minimum age for sending a child to adult. Are we solving youth violence by sending minors to jail in adult prisons?
In the article "Tough Justice for Juveniles" author Edward Humes discusses the underlining problems with the Juvenile Justice System. We need to consider whether we are out to teach them a lesson against committing crimes or turning them into better criminals by locking them up in adult prisons.
The author gave alarming statistics that appealed to my emotion as a.
Youth Violence essays. Are we solving youth violence by sending minors to jail in adult prisons? In the article "Tough Justice for Juveniles" author Edward Humes discusses the underlining problems with the Juvenile Justice System.Download